Where’s the good in Goodmail?
Wednesday, April 12th, 2006Contributed by: Tina Stults
Direct Marketing Manager, Stein Communications
If you have a valid email address, chances are you’ve been spammed. In fact, it’s highly likely that when you sit down at your computer and open your email client, the majority of the messages flooding your inbox originate from email marketers, legitimate or not. You may have even gone to great lengths to protect your email address from spammers by installing a spam blocker service, unsubscribing your address from multiple mailing lists, or changing your email address to restore a moderate (and fleeting) level of anonymity.
But somehow, the spammers always find you.
Of course, there are those companies, institutions, and organizations that are on the up-and-up. Permission-based email marketing is a thriving and rapidly expanding industry, bolstered by its speed, cost efficiency, and ability to reach customers and prospects on a personal level. For most of us, permission-based email marketing is an essential component of our integrated marketing campaigns, supporting other print and interactive media.
Over the past several years, the government and other public and private entities have begun instituting measures with the intent to reign in spammers, whose messages clog our inboxes, and pave the way for legitimate email marketers to communicate more effectively with their target audiences. You’ve heard the words tossed around — CAN-SPAM, spam filters, whitelists — and you’ve likely taken steps to protect your own email address(es) with one or more of these tools. But have you also gotten wind of one of the newest regulatory measures in email marketing — dubbed by some as the “email tax”?
In 2003, a company by the name of Goodmail Systems launched their CertifiedEmail service, “the highest standard in email certification, to provide a safe and reliable class of email for the benefit of consumers, legitimate senders and mailbox providers.” CertifiedEmail essentially requires marketers to provide documentation about their history, credit rating, and commercial email use; companies and organizations that pass the test are charged a fee — approximately $2 per 1,000 messages — to ensure delivery of their email.
AOL and Yahoo! have recently partnered with Goodmail on its CertifiedEmail program, a move that has many email marketers up in arms. Approximately 73.5 million adults — half of the adult population in the U.S. — have registered email addresses with one of the two domains. Under the CertifiedEmail system, approved marketers will pay a premium every time they send a message to a recipient with an AOL or Yahoo! domain name.
So how does the email certification process work in action? Without getting into the weighty details, if you’re trying to send an email and you haven’t been validated by the CertifiedEmail service, your message most likely will be stripped of its images and hyperlinks. Participation in the plan ensures that your recipients will receive the email in its intended form.
Since AOL announced its intent to implement Goodmail’s service, a 50-member coalition — whose roster includes organizations such as MoveOn.org, Civic Action, and Gun Owners of America — has joined forces to fight the initiative, launching a web site at DearAOL.com, where individuals can sign a petition protesting the move, share their opinions through blog posts, and find out how to take further action.
The web site states that “AOL’s ‘email tax’ is the first step down a slippery slope that will harm the Internet itself. The Internet is a revolutionary force for free speech, civic organizing, and economic innovation precisely because it is open and accessible to all Internet users equally.” The site’s open letter to AOL also asserts that the pay-to-send measure won’t prevent spam — “in fact, this plan assumes that spam will continue and that mass mailers will be willing to pay to have their emails bypass spam filters.”
Goodmail, AOL, and Yahoo! stand by their assertion that the certification service is designed to guarantee delivery of emails generated by legitimate organizations while keeping spammers and fraudulent marketers at bay. However, AOL has backpedaled, making the CertifiedEmail service optional and promising to keep the Enhanced Whitelist they’ve used in recent years. They have also stated that “legitimate non-profit and advocacy groups” will not be charged to have emails certified and delivered — good news to many colleges and universities who operate as non-profit institutions.
In the meantime, Yahoo!’s implementation will be limited to “transactional” messages only — bank statements, purchase receipts, etc. The ISP has assured businesses and organizations that they will be able to “send email to Yahoo! email users at no cost in exactly the way they always have.”
There of plenty of people on both side of the fence with opinions about the CertifiedEmail program. Folks on the pro side argue that the Goodmail system will protect legitimate marketers and the integrity of individual email accounts. Opponents cite the tenets of free speech and equal access that are among our most basic rights. Regardless of your position, chances are that for now, your institution is protected by its status as a non-profit. But as our cluttered inboxes have proven, this battle is far from over.